Further Resources
Why Most Leadership EQ Training Is Complete Rubbish (And What Actually Works)
Our Favourite Blogs:
Here's the thing about emotional intelligence training that nobody wants to admit: 87% of it is absolute garbage.
I've been running leadership development programs across Melbourne, Sydney, and Brisbane for the past 18 years, and I can tell you with complete confidence that most emotional intelligence for managers courses are nothing more than expensive feel-good sessions that achieve precisely nothing. Zero. Zip. Nada.
But before you think I'm just another cynical consultant having a whinge, let me explain why this matters and what actually works.
The Problem With Traditional EQ Training
Most emotional intelligence programs follow the same tired formula. They wheel in some overpaid facilitator who spends three hours explaining the difference between sympathy and empathy, gets everyone to take a Myers-Briggs assessment (don't get me started on that pseudoscience), and then runs through role-playing exercises that make everyone cringe.
Sound familiar?
The fundamental issue is that these programs treat emotional intelligence like it's a skill you can learn in a workshop, like using Excel or changing a tyre. It's not. Emotional intelligence is more like fitness - it requires consistent practice, real-world application, and honest feedback. You can't get emotionally fit by attending a seminar any more than you can get physically fit by watching a YouTube video about burpees.
I learned this the hard way back in 2009 when I was working with a manufacturing company in Geelong. Brilliant example of what not to do. We ran a two-day intensive EQ program for their supervisors, complete with certificates and everything. Six months later, nothing had changed. Same conflicts, same communication breakdowns, same frustrated employees.
That's when I realised we were doing it completely wrong.
The Real Challenge: Workplace Politics and Power Dynamics
Here's what the textbooks don't tell you about emotional intelligence in Australian workplaces: it's not about being nice or understanding feelings. It's about navigating power structures, handling office politics, and making tough decisions while maintaining relationships.
Most EQ training completely ignores this reality. They focus on fluffy concepts like "active listening" and "emotional awareness" without addressing the fact that Sarah from Accounts is never going to trust anything you say because you got the promotion she wanted, or that Dave from Operations deliberately undermines every initiative because he's been passed over for management three times.
Real emotional intelligence in leadership means understanding these dynamics and working with them, not pretending they don't exist.
What Actually Works: The Uncomfortable Truth
After nearly two decades in this industry, I've identified three things that actually develop emotional intelligence in leaders. None of them are comfortable. All of them work.
1. Regular 360-Degree Feedback (But Done Properly)
Not the sanitised, HR-approved version where everyone says nice things. I'm talking about honest, specific feedback from people who work with you every day. Anonymous surveys don't cut it either. The best feedback comes from structured conversations with people who have permission to tell you the truth.
Westpac does this brilliantly with their senior leadership team. Regular feedback sessions with direct reports, peers, and managers. No holds barred. It's uncomfortable as hell, but it works.
2. Cross-Functional Secondments
You want to develop emotional intelligence? Try managing a team in a department you don't understand, with people who didn't choose to work for you, solving problems you've never encountered before. It's like emotional intelligence boot camp.
I've seen more leadership growth from three-month secondments than from years of traditional training. When you're forced to influence without authority, you quickly learn what emotional intelligence actually means.
3. Mentoring Difficult People
Here's something controversial: assign your high-potential leaders to mentor your most challenging employees. Not the ones with performance issues - the ones with attitude problems, the cynics, the people who've been around forever and "know better."
It sounds counterintuitive, but these relationships force leaders to develop genuine emotional intelligence. You can't fake empathy with someone who's been burned by empty corporate promises five times before. You have to actually understand their perspective and find ways to connect authentically.
The Australian Factor: Why Context Matters
Something else most EQ programs get wrong: they're designed for generic corporate America. Australian workplace culture is different. We're more direct, more egalitarian, and we have zero tolerance for corporate speak.
A program that works in Dallas might fall completely flat in Darwin. Aussie employees can spot inauthenticity from a kilometre away, and they'll call it out faster than you can say "synergy."
The most effective emotional intelligence training I've seen acknowledges this cultural context. It recognises that effective leadership in Australia often means being straightforward while still being respectful, challenging ideas without attacking people, and building trust through consistency rather than charisma.
Practical Steps That Actually Work
So what should you do instead of booking another generic EQ workshop? Here are five practical strategies that deliver real results:
Start with self-awareness audits. Video record yourself in meetings for two weeks. I know it's painful, but it's the fastest way to see your actual behaviour rather than your intended behaviour. Most leaders are shocked by what they discover.
Implement feedback loops. After every difficult conversation or challenging meeting, ask one person for specific feedback. What worked? What didn't? What would they do differently? Make it a habit, not a one-off exercise.
Practice emotional regulation under pressure. Join Toastmasters, take an improv class, or volunteer to present at industry conferences. You need to practice managing your emotions when stakes are real and stress is high.
Study your team's emotional patterns. Keep a simple log of team dynamics for a month. When do conflicts arise? What triggers stress? Who influences mood? Understanding these patterns is the foundation of emotional intelligence.
Embrace the uncomfortable conversations. Stop avoiding difficult discussions. The more you practice having them, the better you get at managing the emotional complexity they involve.
The Bottom Line: It's About Practice, Not Programs
Here's the brutal truth about emotional intelligence: you can't outsource its development to a training provider. It requires consistent, uncomfortable practice in real situations with real consequences.
The best emotionally intelligent leaders I know didn't get that way through workshops. They got there through years of making mistakes, receiving feedback, and gradually improving their ability to understand and influence human behaviour.
Does this mean all EQ training is worthless? No. But it means you need to be incredibly selective about what you invest in. Look for programs that focus on practical application, provide ongoing support, and acknowledge the messy reality of organisational life.
Most importantly, remember that developing emotional intelligence is a marathon, not a sprint. It takes time, effort, and a willingness to confront some uncomfortable truths about yourself and your leadership style.
But when you get it right, the results speak for themselves. Better team performance, reduced conflict, increased employee engagement, and the kind of workplace culture that actually retains good people.
And in today's competitive market, that's not just nice to have - it's essential for survival.
Related Resources: